What would you present (if only given 2-3 minutes to speak o…

What would you present (if only given 2-3 minutes to speak or 250-300 words to write) as the primary issues concerning the ethical dilemma of illegal immigration, specifically whether the United States government should allow undocumented immigrants (persons in the country illegally) to become U.S. citizens? Review the “Opposing Viewpoints” and “Issues & Controversies” databases located under the course materials folder, as well as the website Procon.org and other scholarly resources for topic help. Cite information from these sources in your response. Just need 125 words.

The ethical dilemma of illegal immigration raises complex issues that require careful analysis and consideration. One primary issue is the question of whether the United States government should allow undocumented immigrants to become U.S. citizens. This topic has sparked intense debate and has polarized opinions.

Proponents of allowing undocumented immigrants to become citizens argue that it is the humane and ethical thing to do. They argue that these individuals often come to the United States seeking better opportunities for themselves and their families, escaping poverty, violence, and political instability in their home countries. Granting them a path to citizenship would provide them with legal protection, access to education, healthcare, and social services, and the ability to fully contribute to society. According to ProCon.org, advocates argue that it aligns with American values of inclusivity, fairness, and compassion. Additionally, they emphasize that many immigrants have deep ties to the United States, including U.S. citizen spouses, children, and other family members. Forcing these families to separate is seen as a violation of human rights and a disruption to the social fabric.

On the other hand, opponents argue that allowing undocumented immigrants to become citizens rewards illegal behavior and undermines the rule of law. They believe that the United States has a responsibility to protect its borders and preserve its sovereignty. They argue that granting citizenship could serve as a pull factor, attracting more undocumented immigrants and potentially exacerbating the issue. According to Opposing Viewpoints, opponents also raise concerns about the strain on public resources and the potential economic impacts of providing citizenship to a large population of undocumented immigrants.

There are also ethical considerations related to the treatment and welfare of undocumented immigrants. Issues surrounding the detention and deportation processes have come under scrutiny. Critics argue that the conditions in detention facilities often fall short of basic human rights standards, leading to concerns about the mistreatment and abuse of individuals awaiting deportation. The idea of separating families through deportation policies has also raised ethical concerns.

Furthermore, the complex nature of the immigration system itself can lead to ethical dilemmas. The lengthy and uncertain processes for legal immigration have contributed to an increase in undocumented immigrants. Critics argue that the heavily bureaucratic system discourages individuals from pursuing legal pathways to immigration and may contribute to their decision to enter the United States illegally. This raises questions about the fairness and accessibility of the legal immigration process.

In conclusion, the ethical dilemma of whether the United States government should allow undocumented immigrants to become U.S. citizens poses a multifaceted challenge. Advocates emphasize the humanitarian and compassionate aspects, while opponents highlight the rule of law and potential economic consequences. There are also ethical concerns surrounding the treatment of undocumented immigrants and the accessibility of the legal immigration process. Examining these issues and considering the perspectives of stakeholders is crucial in developing comprehensive and ethical solutions to this complex problem.